US Cities Eye Ocean Waves For Power Supplies
Author: Leonard Anderson and Timothy Gardner
Whether captured by big buoys bobbing on sea swells, or by submerged turbines spinning with the ebb and flow of the tides, the energy potential of moving water, or marine power, is beginning to turn heads in the energy world.
"I'm pretty bullish on the technology," said Robert Thresher, a wind power researcher at the Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
Thresher said water power has several advantages over wind power, including having a lower profile. One day marine power could catch on like wind power, currently the fastest growing alternative energy, he said.
"It doesn't have the visibility of a wind turbine device," he said. Some critics, famously Massachusetts Democratic Sen. Ted Kennedy, have fought offshore wind farms because they say a forest of tall turbines spoils views of the horizon.
Another advantage, Thresher said, is that water currents are more energy-dense than wind currents --- about 1,000 times more.
"My wind power brethren say their turbines generate more power when it's humid," said Trey Taylor, president of Washington-based Verdant Power, which makes underwater turbines. "I like to say, 'You can't get any more humid than water.'"
Marine power is in its infancy. But an experimental wave project run last summer by Ocean Power Delivery Ltd in the Scottish Orkneys successfully provided power to 500 homes through Scottish Power.
Marine power research has received millions of dollars worth of government subsidies in Scotland, but the United States currently has no federal program.
Still, the potential is high for US waters, even at many of the nation's thousands of dams and rivers. "Just below the Niagara Falls is a fantastic source of energy," Taylor said.
The technology is so young that fish protectors Trout Unlimited have not formed an opinion on wave power. But marine conservation group Surfrider Foundation is "guardedly optimistic" about a system of buoys planned by New Jersey-based Ocean Power Technologies, said spokesman Matt McClain.
EAST RIVER, THE GOLDEN GATE, AND THE GULF STREAM
This May, Verdant Power is scheduled to place as many as six underwater turbines on the bottom of New York City's East River to supply power to a food market on Roosevelt Island in the river, which separates Manhattan from the boroughs of Brooklyn and Queens.
Environmental regulators are examining the plans and weighing possible problems for fish and other marine life.
Verdant says turbines are unlikely to harm animals because their blades are dull, widely spaced, and turn slowly. The company is seeking the go-ahead to install as many as 200 to 300 turbines in the East River.
River debris also is a concern, but crews could change the turbines frequently, according to Taylor.
The expanded project would produce five to 10 megawatts of electricity at an initial cost of $20 million, but New York state as a whole, Taylor said, could produce about 1,000 megawatts, or power for about 1 million homes. The fuel source is free.
Roger Bedard of think tank Electric Power Research Institute in Palo Alto, California, said the amount of wave energy available off the coasts of the United States is nine to 10 times the energy currently generated by the country's hydroelectric dams.
The city of San Francisco is studying harnessing the power of offshore waves as well as ocean tides that surge beneath the Golden Gate Bridge. It's looking at clean power as an option to replace two old power stations fired by natural gas.
"The city has an advantage because we sit at the tip of a peninsula with water on three sides," said Jared Blumenfeld, director of San Francisco's Environment Department. "We can do what makes sense for our geography."
The city is working on a demonstration project with Scotland's Ocean Power. The company's Orkney project uses a floating steel cylindrical device, about the length of four train cars, with sect